Case Study: Turning a 35% Increase into a $160K Savings

When renewal costs spike, creative solutions matter.

The Challenge

A mid-sized employer was blindsided by a significant renewal increase. Neither the company nor its employees could absorb the additional premium without making painful budget cuts or cost shifts.

How Pancoast Helped

Referred to us by a trusted partner, the client was seeking a creative alternative to an unsustainable renewal. We redesigned their PPO plan, introduced a high-deductible health plan (HDHP) with an employer-funded HSA contribution, and restructured contributions, ensuring no added cost to employees.

Results

  • 35% reduction in projected costs
  • $160,000 in annual savings
  • No change in employee contributions

Unexpected Wins

Enrollment in the HDHP exceeded expectations, and employees were genuinely grateful for the financial stability it offered, especially during a time when rising premiums seemed inevitable.

Why It Matters

The decision-maker was celebrated internally for her leadership and cost-saving strategy, earning credibility with the executive team and appreciation from employees.

Our Impact

With creative plan design and clear communication tools, we helped transform a looming financial challenge into a win for both leadership and staff, demonstrating the power of Pancoast’s consultative approach.

Facing a Tough Renewal?

We help clients navigate complex cost challenges with clarity and creativity.